Poll: Should caravans have an annual MOT?

Published in Polls on   - 31 Comments

How would you rate this article?

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (6 votes, average: 4.50 out of 5)
Loading...

Comments


  1. Jon Meddings says:

    As a caravan owner of 7 years yes I do think they should have an MOT. There should be an exemption though for owners who have their caravan serviced every year, as the service would pretty much cover everything and more that an MOT would check.

  2. Pete From Bristol says:

    Still recovering from the trauma of getting my car through the MOT last year (on the first ay of the new regulations). So my bad self says ‘no caravan MOT’. Luckily my good self makes sure I have the caravan checked and serviced to within an inch of its life every year…

  3. William Bowmar says:

    I would NOT Happy with an annual MOT, perhaps every three years would be ok. If dealers offer a better service and had to carry out habitation checks that would le be better.

    I store my Van at a CAssoa LOCATION where some vans are in an awful state. I note one can has not moved for 4 years.

  4. Philip Humphries says:

    Surely if you have your van serviced annually to the NCC standard it’s as good if not better than an MOT. On the road a van still has to be road legal, how many vanners know their weights, loading, gross train weights for. C licence legality etc.

  5. D J IBBOTT says:

    As a road going vehicle weighing in at 1 to 2 tonnes it needs to be treated like any other road-going vehicle. I learned the hard way about tyres that had good tread depth but were past their best before date. Dealers could carry out an MOT as part of an annual service but would they need to be registered as MOT test centres?

  6. Paul Gough says:

    It will come in eventually…yes we can all check our lights etc, but can we judge our braking efficiency? And has anybody tried obtaining a tork wrench (really high setting) to really inspect your pads…
    The probable possible good news if it comes in, is a normal MOT station is better suited (rolling road) and cheaper…and if truth be known most people with not so new caravans would dump a £200 service for a £50 MOT..but with site prices rising, insurance,club annual fees, breakdown cover, deprecation of the van…one wonders if it makes sense anymore

  7. Tony Copley.CAE.FIMI. says:

    As an MOT inspector I think that an MOT for caravans would be a great idea to boost the profits of caravan dealers with very little help to road safety. The biggest cause of caravan accidents are due to inexperience of drivers and the need to replace tyres after the recommended time as they can crack on side walls and deteriorate well before they wear out.

  8. John Phelps says:

    NO to caravan MOT’s.
    Check lights, hitch, tyre condition, tyre pressures and brakes before you go. Same responsibilities as your tow vehicle.

  9. pete kilfoyle says:

    I agree with Geoff Porter. I started out as an auto electrician just before the mot was introduced covering brakes,steering,tyres and hardly anything else. Over the years this has risen to almost everything mechanical, electrical and glass. this has meant that the mot can fail you on almost anything now and unscrupulous dealers/garages are known to take advantage of this. I feel that some caravan service centers could be incentivised to do the same

  10. Roger Parnell says:

    all trailers and caravans should be tested, i work in the motor trade and we see some very poor condition towed vehicles.

  11. Rex Beech says:

    My caravan is serviced by an approved engineer every year. A certificate and a sticker are provided. It is in ones own interest to ensure contemporary, hi-tec vans are regularly serviced to avoid costly repairs. When insurance claims are dealt with the regularity and frequency of competent servicing should be taken into account.

  12. Ralph Brunjes says:

    I do not think an mot but I do think a service of some kind even if it is a dig job.
    I think it should be a check list type so that it can cover road worthiness and insurance cover. But not like a car mot.

  13. roger miller says:

    my luner stella has always been serviced from new i do not see the need to bring in mot for
    caravans it is up to the owners of caravans to look after them.I am sure the police will take
    a dim view of any caravan that causes an accident.

  14. Robert Kirk says:

    No MOT, regular servicing is sufficient. I am interested in knowing how many claims were made and dismissed due to poor condition of the caravans mechanical elements regardless of the cause of the accident.or incident. What do the insurance company’s think, do they want an MOT.

    • We’ve hardly ever had any claims where a caravan has been found to be in a poor condition. But we understand if a mechanical element of the caravan fails during towing the consequences can be catastrophic so we can see both sides of the argument. The worry would be is that it would deter some careful caravan owners from continuing to tour due to additional costs and time of having the tests carried out each year.

  15. Debbie Pearce says:

    You can’t put a price on safety and not all of us are capable of doing our own servicing..
    MOTs are a good idea!

  16. Roy luck says:

    I whole heartedly agree with Geof, It would be a cash cow most caravan owners check their vans before the winter and after. I payed over two hundreds pounds to have my van serviced which included checking brakes a bit of grease on moving parts. BUT it is mainly for the warranty of the van, Look what has crept in on cars now, completely different to years ago.

  17. Andrew says:

    It seems that there are many who would see compulsary MOTs for caravans as a nice lucrative little earner for them and it would the poor carvanner who has to pay. read; ripped off. Also, vehicles registered as Historic (over 40 years old)do not need a MOT and road tax is free…… Although it does have to be applied for. Would this 40 year rule apply to caravans as well?? It would be interesting to find out.

  18. Bob Collin. says:

    Perhaps not a full MOT. Although an annual service could be compulsory to ensure safety, tyres, battery, electric and gas.

  19. margaret seed says:

    Again, thin end of the wedge. How long before we have to pay RFL?

  20. Tim Alder says:

    I think that safety is important but an mot would be a money maker, road side checks should be more common.
    Service costs are now quite expensive now, and having a annual service sticker on the aframe is a good visual check at any time to see if the caravan has been maintained.

  21. David Armstrong says:

    I fully agree with Geoff Porters comments. For personal reasons my wife & I did not use our caravan last year,so an MOT would have been completly un-necessary & waste of money. We continued to use our car though,as it was indispensible! Our van will have a service this year before we commence towing again

  22. m. currie says:

    The amount of caravans now on the road and looking at the conditions of some of them are in will tell you if it’s been looked after …motorhome and campervan have to have a m.o.t on the 3rd year from new so why not .. do you know if your brakes are worn do change the tyres after 5 years old.

  23. George Wade says:

    If caravans were all serviced annually, as they should be, there is no need for a separate mot.any problems should be picked up and put right at the service.

  24. Stephen Ellison says:

    Don’t think( m o t ) is ness/ but I do think should be serviced , each year, this could be proof that caravan is being looked after we always have our service recipt with us when touring saying that our last van .2017 service did 30 miles after service and both wheels sized up ? this happened (lucky) at a caravan dealers unlucky as I was part exchanging it ????

  25. Mr Alan Maughan says:

    Don’t trust some dealers on servicing and, another money making exercise I think. Its like cars. You can get a cheap MOT offer but they always screw you for something. My last one was a few flakes of orange lacquer on the indicator bulbs. They said they were showing white light, impossible to tell as the lenses are frosted. New ones made no difference only ripped off to bump the price of the MOT back up to normal price.
    I know for a fact that some caravan dealers don’t check the brakes on servicing. after servicing, I had to do a job and found that the red paint line on the hub nut hadn’t been touched even though they charged me for one shot nuts.
    They tried to tell me they re painted the line back on.
    This is why I think its a bad idea

    • Sorry to hear of your bad caravan servicing experience. We’re sure most dealers perform a very genuine and thorough caravan service, particularly if they’re a member of the Approved Workshop Scheme.

  26. Andrew Culley says:

    This issue is one that could be very effectively argued either way!
    Firstly, many owners take great care of their (expensive) caravans and ensure that everything is serviced and well maintained. I would say that covers the majority. So why impose yet more bureaucracy on them for no good reason?
    Then there are the “well if it works why spend money checking or maintaining it” and it’s those type of users that would be most effected (in a positive manner) by any compulsory test.
    Then there is the question of what exactly would be tested? Logically there would be just four items, tyres, brakes, lights and finally (possibly) structural Integrety.
    After all of that how would the lack of testing actually be enforced? The caravan doesn’t have its own registration mark (unlike many EU countries) so it’s MOT status cannot be checked by roadside ANPR cameras (like car MOT and insurance is) So it would rely solely on a police officer physically requesting sight of its MOT certificate, at the time the caravan is actually present on a road (which in any 12 month period will, in all likelihood be very minimal anyway) and when was the last time you even HEARD of, let alone experienced, a car being stopped by a police officer?
    An interesting idea, but when you look into the practicalities it’s not so simple as it first appears.
    Me? I think the juries out on the need for caravans to be MOT’d!
    Andy C

  27. Fiona Keates says:

    After 3 (or 5?) years, like a car. For road worthiness (tyres, brakes etc) and safety issues such as gas and electrics. That way, you know its safe to tow and use.
    Cars also have a service on top for preventative care, which is not maditory but recommend, same should be for caravans.

  28. Bernard Rawcliffe says:

    After 3 years the same as cars

  29. Geoff Porter says:

    Caravan MOT’s could be a cash cow for caravan dealers with service departments. Road safety is obviously very important so if any MOT was introduced it should be for caravan running order issues. Many caravanners are more than competent and do their own service and maintainance, who is to say a service engineer would do the job better and make the caravan safer. If an MOT was introduced I have a suspicion that it would develop over years to cover all sorts of minor issues. A couple of years ago this was under consideration by the Eu, a lot us us wrote to out MEP’s expressing our displeasure. I would sooner see public money being spent on more worthwhile and easier administered schemes. To put things into perspective what record is there of incidents involving caravans giving blame to inadequate caravan maintenance. I would have thought the majority of incidents occur because of excessive speed for the road conditions.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *



Why Choose us?
Defaqto 2015 Logo
Caravan insurance with a 5 Star Rating
Number 1 on ReviewCentre
Number 1 for service and value
RSA Logo
Reassuringly good cover from a leading insurer
Award winning customer service
Award winning customer service
Norton Secure online quotes
Safe and secure online quotes
Trusted family business since 1984
Confidence in a trusted family business
claiments rate our service as good or exceptional
Claimants rate our service as good or exceptional
Great value icon
Great value for money
Money back guarantee
Money back guarantee
NCC Logo
Member of the National Caravan Council
Heart Research Logo
Heart Research donation with every paperless policy
Plain English policy icon
Plain English policy and documents